Home » Education » BRAIN: The Differences between Emergentism and Skill Acquisition Theory


April 2017
« Mar   Jun »

Read these articles

  • BRAIN: Business Process Management – An Interesting ApproachBRAIN: Business Process Management – An Interesting Approach
    In the latest volume of the BRAIN journal, Roberto Paiano, Adriana Caione, Anna Lisa Guido, Angelo Martella and Andrea Pandurino have come up with an interesting research on the Business Process Development, a traditional approach vs. …
  • Women and Girls in STEMWomen and Girls in STEM
    STEM education has become more and more important, and it is required for an interconnected global economy. The acronym refers to a range of academic disciplines, such as science, technology, engineering, and mathematics, meant to …
  • LiBRI: The Sacred in Literature and Arts
    We all know that the sacred is present in our lives, but sometimes we cannot understand it and perceive it. This paper represents and endeavor of synthesizing knowledge from the field of arts, literature, art …
  • SMART 2016 – Pre-conference MOOCSMART 2016 – Pre-conference MOOC
    This MOOC consists of selected conference presentations as short videos that demonstrate the main outcomes of the authors’ contributions. The scope is to enhance the discussions and exchange between the participants in the conference and …
  • BRAND: Mediation – The Wise Advocacy
    Antagonistic prosecution is not by any means the only method for determining debate and settling of cases. There are different alternatives. Elective method for debate determination can spare cash and time, and can grapple and …
  • BRAIN: Integrating MOOCs in Embedded Systems Blended Courses
    The Massive Open Online Course (MOOC) phenomenon has been growing in popularity and importance in the last decade, receiving valuable recognition from renowned universities from all over the world. MOOC can be simply defined as …
  • SMART 2017 International Conference
    Here are some of the photos that were taken at SMART 2017 International Conference. You can find more on our facebook page. We want to thank all of the participants for the effort placed in their research …
  • LiBRI: The Relationship Between Metacognitive Strategy Use, Good Language Learner, and Iranian Learner’s Willingness to Communicate
    The explanation of the relationship between metacognitive strategies, learner characteristics and willingness to communicate is a highly important aspect when speaking about foreign language teaching and learning processes. Considering this, Gholam-Reza Abbasian and Bahareh Hoodin …
  • LiBRI: Obsessive Contradictions in ”Pădurea Spânzuraților”
    “Pădurea Spânzuraţilor” written by Liviu Rebreanu is a complex novel whose fundamental theme is the inner conflict. The paper Obsessive Contradictions in ”Pădurea spânzuraților” written by Florentina Gabriela Stroe is aimed at highlighting the protagonist’s struggle …
  • BRAND: Effect of Professionalism, Competence, Knowledge of Financial ManagementBRAND: Effect of Professionalism, Competence, Knowledge of Financial Management
    In the latest volume of the BRAND, Darwanis Darwanis, Mulia Saputra and Kartini Kartini prove to what extent the condition of financial reporting area is influenced by the professionalism, competence, knowledge of financial management and …
  • BRAIN : A Synoptic of Software Implementation for Shift Registers Based on 16th Degree Primitive Polynomials
    BRAIN journal has recently published a research paper A Synoptic Of Software Implementation For Shift Registers Based On 16th Degree Primitive Polynomials developed by Mirella Amelia Mioc from Suceava, Romania. All of the significant applications in …
  • BRAIN: Social Media in Science EducationBRAIN: Social Media in Science Education
    The latest volume of the BRAIN Journal has a new intriguing research on Training Teachers for the Knowledge Society: Social Media in Science Education  offered by Dana Crăciun and Mădălin Bunoiu from West University of …


BRAIN: The Differences between Emergentism and Skill Acquisition Theory

When speaking about emergentism we mainly refer to the interaction between organism and environment and that denies the existence of pre-determined, domain specific faculties or capacities. In language acquisition, emergentists state that simple learning mechanisms are sufficient to bring about the emergence of complex language representations.

The representation of neural network in connectionism
The representation of neural network in connectionism

There are two types of emergentism. On the one hand, there is one type based on input, which is the input-based emergentism (emergentist-connectionist model). On the other hand, there is the one that considers the role of the processing working memory, which, however, does not ignore the contribution of the input to the process of language acquisition, but emphasizes on the frequency of occurrence.

Skill acquisition is a theory in the field of cognitive science. It is believed that learning a language is quite similar to learning other skills such as driving a car or playing the piano. This theory mentions that language learning involves different stages of the cognitive process. Like other skills, it starts with conscious attention, controlled processing and effort, but through practice, it will lead to automaticity. For example, when someone wants to learn how to drive a car, they need to pay attention to different aspects at the same time. However, through practice, one could automatically drive a car with less attention. In skill acquisition theory, there is a movement from declarative to procedural knowledge. This theory explains the underlying knowledge which is required to achieve a specific skill, and the productive skills are the representation of the system which has been internalized.

Considering the underlying assumptions, these two theories fall within different cognitive theories. A first aspect is that skill acquisition is considered as a psycholinguistic model, suggesting that language is similar to other cognitive processes. Psycholinguistics shows that language skill is the result of earlier language use and it is affected by the learner’s practice and experience with the language and the world. Researchers showed that this function applies to a wide range of skills including cigar rolling, syllogistic reasoning, book writing, industrial production, reading inverted text and lexical decision. On the other hand, emergentism draws both on social-interactionist and nativist theories by mainly focusing both on the role of input and innate mechanisms in the process of language learning. Children are born with neurons and brain which make them able to acquire language.

By elaborating on different models of knowledge, scientists draw on another distinction. Symbolic models such as skill acquisition and Emergentist connectionist models are different on how they represent knowledge. Skill acquisition contains a component of declarative and a component of the procedural organization, while the Emergentist connectionist models is a type of architecture in which knowledge is represented not only by means of symbols but also in a distributed way, as a pattern of activation in a neural network containing hidden units.

Another difference between these theories is related to their views towards the role of implicit knowledge. Skill acquisition theory results from automatized explicit knowledge which is usually achieved through practice, while in emergentist theories implicit knowledge develops during meaning-focused communication, aided, perhaps, by some focus on form. Furthermore, these two theories also differ with respect to the role of input. Emergentism is based on input. One type of this approach is based on input and it is called input-based emergentism. However, skill acquisition is believed to be based on output and it is mainly concerned with language behaviors.

As a result, depending on the purpose of instruction, each of these theories could be taken by practitioners. If the focus is on the developmental stages of language learning, practice, and then the final output, the skill acquisition theory would suit the context. However, if the focus is on the characteristics of input and input manipulation, emergentism would be the practical underlying theory.

Read more here!

Gabriela Tăbăcaru